⚠️

Risk scores are statistical indicators based on prescribing patterns compared to specialty peers. They are NOT allegations of fraud, misconduct, or improper care. Many legitimate medical reasons can explain outlier prescribing.

Read our methodology →

Shelly CarnevaleRN

Nurse Practitioner · Grand Rapids, MI 49546

NPI: 1326567413

Share:

33

🟠 Elevated

Risk Flags

Very high opioid rate vs specialty peers90th percentile opioid prescribingHigh long-acting opioid rate vs peers

Risk indicators are statistical patterns, not allegations. Learn more

2,729

Total Claims

$178K

Drug Cost

365

Beneficiaries

$487

Cost/Patient

Risk Score Breakdown 33/100

Low (0)Moderate (15)Elevated (30)High (50+)
Opioid rate vs specialty peers+18
Long-acting opioid rate+8
Opioid rate (national percentile)+5

Score components are additive. Read full methodology

Peer Comparison vs. 218,535 Nurse Practitioner providers

+984%

Opioid rate vs peers

41.0% vs 3.8% avg

-59%

Cost per patient vs peers

$487 vs $1,174 avg

-54%

Brand preference vs peers

4.1% vs 8.9% avg

⚠️ This provider has metrics more than 3 standard deviations above their specialty average in one or more categories.

🔎 Data Overview

⚠️

Opioid prescribing rate is 984% above the average for Nurse Practitioner providers. While some providers legitimately treat pain-heavy populations, deviations of this magnitude are rare and warrant examination.

Insights generated from CMS data analysis. Statistical patterns are not accusations — always consider clinical context.

Opioid Prescribing

41.0%

Opioid Rate

1,119

Opioid Claims

$112K

Opioid Cost

27.1%

Long-Acting Rate

This provider's opioid prescribing rate of 41.0% is above the 20% threshold that CMS considers elevated.

Brand vs Generic

96% generic

Brand: 112 claims · $59K

Generic: 2,617 claims · $119K

Patient Profile

67

Avg Age

69%

Female

1.29

Avg Risk Score

Explore More

Data from CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber Public Use File, 2023. Risk scores are statistical indicators, not allegations.Methodology · About